Question to BOINC-wide Teams
Question to BOINC-wide Teams

Advanced search

Message boards : Web interfaces : Question to BOINC-wide Teams

AuthorMessage
Profile Saenger
Avatar
Send message
Joined: Nov 9 05
Posts: 104
Message 13351 - Posted 28 Oct 2007 20:07:30 UTC

    A 'BOINC-wide team' is one that teams that exist on all BOINC projects, present and future, with an identical name and founder email address.

    [snip]

    1. Create an account and a team on this site. If you already have a team on one or more BOINC projects, use the exact same team name and email address.

    [snip]

    The list of teams and accounts on this site is periodically imported by each BOINC project. Teams and accounts that don't already exist on that project are added. If the team exists and is owned by you (i.e. its founder has the same email address), then its URL, description etc. are updated.

    [snip]

    * The email address and team name you use on this site should never be changed (if you change them, you'll need to manually change them on every BOINC project in order for updates to work). Pick an email address that won't go away any time soon.

    [snip]

    Our team has many founders, and I think that's fine. A founder should be someone who really crunches for the project, not just someone who has some whatever position in a team.

    The above quoted lines suggest that the future dealing should be something centralist, with one head honcho and a lot of servants, that's not my idea of a good management.

    We are considering a central mail address atm, something more than just one person has access to, but imho it will still be just the starter, afterwards the founder will probably go to someone personal, who crunches in this project and is responsible for keeping the team description up to date.

    BTW, team description is of course something else in all projects, not some prefab airy-fairy one-size-fits-all. That's may be a good starter for new projects, until you have the time to customise it, but not for updating it once in a while. It should be different on all projects.

    So, on one hand it seems like a fine idea to have the name SETI.Germany kind of copyrighted in new projects from the beginning, but any update should just be a voluntarily option, something to suppress for teams that don't want such a uniformity, that are a bit more diverse.

    How is this handled?
    How are teams with diverse founders, that want to stay so, handled with the described updates?
    ____________
    Grüße vom Sänger


    For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

    mo.v
    Avatar
    Send message
    Joined: Aug 13 06
    Posts: 585
    Message 13356 - Posted 29 Oct 2007 3:15:16 UTC

      I suspect I may be the only, or one of the few, members of my team (Catalunya) who know about this. There are multiple founders. They are mostly interested in organising group talks, meetings and dinners in sunny and elegant or historical places. When I've worked out in my own mind what would have to be done to change things, I may consider asking them about it.

      The advantage of becoming a BOINC-wide team is, as you say, having the team name reserved in advance on new projects. As the number of projects grows, this aspect will become more important.

      Profile Saenger
      Avatar
      Send message
      Joined: Nov 9 05
      Posts: 104
      Message 13398 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 13:06:26 UTC

        Anyone of the developers with an answer to my question?

        How is this BOINC-wide teams list supposed to work with multi-founder teams?

        And what is suposed to happen with customised team descriptions for each project? I fail to see a click box "Do update team profile on existing teams yes/no"
        ____________
        Grüße vom Sänger


        For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

        Profile Ageless
        Forum moderator
        Project administrator
        Avatar
        Send message
        Joined: Aug 29 05
        Posts: 4384
        Message 13405 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 16:44:12 UTC - in response to Message 13398.

          How is this BOINC-wide teams list supposed to work with multi-founder teams?

          Not. Only one team founder per team is possible through there. Or you use the all-in-one email address as the workaround.
          Else, don't use BOINC Teams.

          And what is suposed to happen with customised team descriptions for each project? I fail to see a click box "Do update team profile on existing teams yes/no"

          They get overwritten if you use the teams option. Only the description you have on here will be used. As it says:

          "The list of teams and accounts on this site is periodically imported by each BOINC project. Teams and accounts that don't already exist on that project are added. If the team exists and is owned by you (i.e. its founder has the same email address), then its URL, description etc. are updated."
          ____________
          Jord

          -The BOINC FAQ Service

          -CUDA/Stream FAQ

          Courtesy starts with your first post of the thread.

          Profile Saenger
          Avatar
          Send message
          Joined: Nov 9 05
          Posts: 104
          Message 13406 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:04:34 UTC

            So there is no use for this "feature" for the second bigest team in BOINC, SETI.Germany.

            To keep the same founder address may be usable, even for bigger teams, if some fake account is used to which more than one member have access, but the team description has to be project individual, not some boring, nonsensical, blah-blah without specialities for this project.

            We have 28 founders on the BOINC projects, and we have a different description on all projects, with a standard part and some custom part in it. This has to stay this way, diversity is better than uniformity. If this "feature" will one day mess with our teams presentation, I think we will get unpleasant.

            Who led this half-baked "feature" lose on the public?
            ____________
            Grüße vom Sänger


            For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

            Profile Ageless
            Forum moderator
            Project administrator
            Avatar
            Send message
            Joined: Aug 29 05
            Posts: 4384
            Message 13407 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:16:18 UTC

              If there's a BOINC-wide team X with founder Y,
              then on new projects team X will be created with founder Y.
              Team X on existing projects (possibly with different founders)
              won't be changed.
              -- David
              ____________
              Jord

              -The BOINC FAQ Service

              -CUDA/Stream FAQ

              Courtesy starts with your first post of the thread.

              zombie67
              Avatar
              Send message
              Joined: Feb 14 06
              Posts: 109
              Message 13408 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:20:40 UTC - in response to Message 13351.

                So, on one hand it seems like a fine idea to have the name SETI.Germany kind of copyrighted in new projects from the beginning...


                It doesn't even do that. Consider this scenario:

                New project, where membership is still invitation only. Team Foo is automatically created, yet no team members from Foo can join at this time. So random person Bar decides to hijack the team by initiating the transfer request.

                Oh yeah, and the default founder no longer exists, as is the case for my own team. How he got set up as the default team founder is a mystery to me and my team. I am guessing the default teams were simply copied from SETI, where he is also founder.

                ____________
                Dublin, CA
                SETI.USA
                Stats
                My stuff
                BOINC IRC chat

                zombie67
                Avatar
                Send message
                Joined: Feb 14 06
                Posts: 109
                Message 13409 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:21:23 UTC - in response to Message 13406.

                  Who led this half-baked "feature" lose on the public?


                  Half-baked is too kind.
                  ____________
                  Dublin, CA
                  SETI.USA
                  Stats
                  My stuff
                  BOINC IRC chat

                  Profile Ageless
                  Forum moderator
                  Project administrator
                  Avatar
                  Send message
                  Joined: Aug 29 05
                  Posts: 4384
                  Message 13410 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:28:03 UTC

                    I've asked for a transparent team description option, or an option to check/uncheck if you want the description to propagate to other projects.
                    ____________
                    Jord

                    -The BOINC FAQ Service

                    -CUDA/Stream FAQ

                    Courtesy starts with your first post of the thread.

                    Profile Saenger
                    Avatar
                    Send message
                    Joined: Nov 9 05
                    Posts: 104
                    Message 13411 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:28:04 UTC - in response to Message 13408.

                      Oh yeah, and the default founder no longer exists, as is the case for my own team. How he got set up as the default team founder is a mystery to me and my team. I am guessing the default teams were simply copied from SETI, where he is also founder.


                      Same here, fortunately he changed his email address to the one of our former homepage admin (who isn't in this position any longer, but still has contact to the current admins). I don't think Chris has voluntarily set up this team here, it was just copied and pasted from Seti without asking the founders about this.
                      ____________
                      Grüße vom Sänger


                      For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

                      mo.v
                      Avatar
                      Send message
                      Joined: Aug 13 06
                      Posts: 585
                      Message 13412 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:36:59 UTC

                        (Aside)
                        I don't think the Catalans are ready for This yet, or This for the Catalans. Like Manuel in Fawlty Towers they would all say 'Qué??????'.

                        Profile Ageless
                        Forum moderator
                        Project administrator
                        Avatar
                        Send message
                        Joined: Aug 29 05
                        Posts: 4384
                        Message 13413 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:38:10 UTC - in response to Message 13410.

                          I've asked for a transparent team description option, or an option to check/uncheck if you want the description to propagate to other projects.

                          For now, BOINC-wide teams will have the same description on all projects. Changing this is possible but not right now.

                          -- David
                          ____________
                          Jord

                          -The BOINC FAQ Service

                          -CUDA/Stream FAQ

                          Courtesy starts with your first post of the thread.

                          Profile Saenger
                          Avatar
                          Send message
                          Joined: Nov 9 05
                          Posts: 104
                          Message 13414 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 17:43:46 UTC - in response to Message 13413.

                            Last modified: 31 Oct 2007 18:25:01 UTC

                            I've asked for a transparent team description option, or an option to check/uncheck if you want the description to propagate to other projects.

                            For now, BOINC-wide teams will have the same description on all projects. Changing this is possible but not right now.

                            -- David


                            Who decided that this boring uniformity had to be the only option?

                            And why were the founders not asked about this, as Chris was most definitely not?

                            This is another fine example of a "feature" hastily implemented, not really thought through, but thrust on the unprepared public before testing and debugging. Fortunately most projects haven't yet implemented this piece of crap in the server code.

                            Edith says:
                            I think I'll open a new ticket about this bug.
                            ____________
                            Grüße vom Sänger


                            For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

                            Profile Saenger
                            Avatar
                            Send message
                            Joined: Nov 9 05
                            Posts: 104
                            Message 13419 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 22:32:31 UTC - in response to Message 13414.

                              Last modified: 31 Oct 2007 22:32:57 UTC

                              Edith says:
                              I think I'll open a new ticket about this bug.

                              My ticket was closed by davea with the ridiculous remark about some dubious google group. WTF has this data mining company to do with this project? Google is no serious provider, they are just an information sucker without any sense of privacy.

                              Ain't this or the different mailing lists and project fora the only valid discussion places? Using google devaluates the merit of this enterprise quite considerably.

                              If this was discussed in this shady back room on google, I have no doubt that no good could have come out of that.
                              ____________
                              Grüße vom Sänger


                              For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

                              Nicolas
                              Avatar
                              Send message
                              Joined: Jan 19 07
                              Posts: 1125
                              Message 13420 - Posted 31 Oct 2007 22:59:06 UTC - in response to Message 13419.

                                My ticket was closed by davea with the ridiculous remark about some dubious google group. WTF has this data mining company to do with this project? Google is no serious provider, they are just an information sucker without any sense of privacy.

                                Ain't this or the different mailing lists and project fora the only valid discussion places? Using google devaluates the merit of this enterprise quite considerably.

                                Using Google Groups would be a good idea if they actually provided something more than what we already have. But nope; this forum has far more features than Google Groups. The main advantage of newsgroups vs web forums is having them accessible offline and without a browser; advantages that were stripped out by Google's web interface.
                                ____________
                                Please use the "Reply" button on posts, instead of "reply to this thread". Keep the "X is a reply to Y".

                                Profile Saenger
                                Avatar
                                Send message
                                Joined: Nov 9 05
                                Posts: 104
                                Message 13487 - Posted 3 Nov 2007 1:13:36 UTC

                                  From the dubious Google-group, probably by David Anderson, as long as it's not here or in the trac I can't say for sure:

                                  I'm preparing to add a "team admin" feature.
                                  The current plan is as follows; please review and comment.

                                  - A team founder can select members of that team as "admins"
                                  (if an admin quits the team, he/she ceases to be an admin)
                                  - An admin of a team can:
                                  - edit its name/URL/description/type/country
                                  - remove members
                                  - view the member list (w/ email addrs)
                                  - An admin cannot:
                                  - change the founder, or accept a change-founder request
                                  - add or remove admins

                                  -- David


                                  What is this dubious group about? It's not a proper place for discussions. It's now readable without surrendering your privacy to the "Datenkrake" Google, but it's definitely no proper place for discussions about BOINC.

                                  There is this official forum to talk about such stuff or the dev-list, full stop. Everything else is just BS.

                                  How should this be implemented?
                                  Will it be possible to join teams on the BOINC-wide team page in the future?
                                  Can a founder transfer be made then?
                                  Will there be an option to keep different descriptions for different projects?
                                  How will multi-founder teams have to use this feature?
                                  ____________
                                  Grüße vom Sänger


                                  For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

                                  zombie67
                                  Avatar
                                  Send message
                                  Joined: Feb 14 06
                                  Posts: 109
                                  Message 13488 - Posted 3 Nov 2007 5:40:18 UTC - in response to Message 13487.

                                    What is this dubious group about? It's not a proper place for discussions. It's now readable without surrendering your privacy to the "Datenkrake" Google, but it's definitely no proper place for discussions about BOINC.

                                    There is this official forum to talk about such stuff or the dev-list, full stop. Everything else is just BS.


                                    It sure does appear like smoke-filled, back-room decisions are being made. It appears that *some* team founders were invited to join this google group, created by David Anderson, back in July. I assume the list of invited founders was taken from the S@H list of team founders. My team was not invited, probably because my team's S@H founder no longer exists. In any case, that the discussion was hidden, and not here or the mailing list is more than a bit frustrating. Or did I miss an announce about this group somewhere official?

                                    I did find this bit of official documentation:

                                    http://boinc.berkeley.edu/trac/wiki/TeamDiscussion

                                    ____________
                                    Dublin, CA
                                    SETI.USA
                                    Stats
                                    My stuff
                                    BOINC IRC chat

                                    Profile Saenger
                                    Avatar
                                    Send message
                                    Joined: Nov 9 05
                                    Posts: 104
                                    Message 13492 - Posted 3 Nov 2007 10:23:59 UTC - in response to Message 13488.

                                      Last modified: 3 Nov 2007 10:46:10 UTC


                                      I did find this bit of official documentation:

                                      http://boinc.berkeley.edu/trac/wiki/TeamDiscussion

                                      I even found some more information there in the change log:
                                      It would be nice if teams were actually BOINC-wide. 6 How do we deal with the situation where the same team name exists 7 on different projects with different owners? 8 9 * Should teams be BOINC-wide rather than project specific? 10 * If so, how to resolve current inconsistencies? 11 * Should people be able to belong to different teams on different projects? 12 13 Conclusion (implemented as of 25 July 2007): 14 * Create a [http://boinc.berkeley.edu/teams/ web site for registering BOINC-wide teams]. 15 * In case of dispute over a name, the oldest instance of the team on an existing project wins. 16 * Write an "export" script to export the list of teams and founders as XML. Include "previous founder" field. 17 * Write an "update" script that downloads these files. For each team: if it doesn't exist, create it, and create user account. If founder in DB is previous founder in XML, change founder. Update other team fields (URL etc.). 18 * Newly-created projects to use the update script (e.g. put in config.xml). 19 * Resolve current inconsistencies manually; I will encourage project admins to help.


                                      It was deleted from the page by:
                                      Author:
                                      davea (IP: 130.75.117.49)
                                      Timestamp:
                                      09/13/07 02:01:53 (2 months ago)


                                      All real changes up to today were made by davea, so it's not really a discussion but a monologue.


                                      Edith says:
                                      I've looked in the dev_list at about that time, I didn't find any hint about it in the logs. I think it was never ever properly discussed, just implemented like some few users wanted it.
                                      ____________
                                      Grüße vom Sänger


                                      For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

                                      Profile Saenger
                                      Avatar
                                      Send message
                                      Joined: Nov 9 05
                                      Posts: 104
                                      Message 13670 - Posted 8 Nov 2007 17:07:03 UTC

                                        David Anderson was active again without using the proper means of communication but the shady back room. He has changed the team founder possibilities, and implemented this already on Seti, SetiBeta and BOINC Alpha:

                                        Team founders can nominate Admins, who can change team description and such. They have access to the email addresses of the team members as well (something the users were not aware of while signing to the team, imho a breach of privacy).
                                        ____________
                                        Grüße vom Sänger


                                        For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

                                        Nicolas
                                        Avatar
                                        Send message
                                        Joined: Jan 19 07
                                        Posts: 1125
                                        Message 13671 - Posted 8 Nov 2007 17:49:04 UTC - in response to Message 13670.

                                          David Anderson was active again without using the proper means of communication but the shady back room. He has changed the team founder possibilities, and implemented this already on Seti, SetiBeta and BOINC Alpha.

                                          He didn't even ask other projects about the ideas, or other developers about the implementation. Then that's why I read "Things we didn't get around to: BOINC protocols as Internet standards" and fall off chair laughing.

                                          ____________
                                          Please use the "Reply" button on posts, instead of "reply to this thread". Keep the "X is a reply to Y".

                                          Profile Ageless
                                          Forum moderator
                                          Project administrator
                                          Avatar
                                          Send message
                                          Joined: Aug 29 05
                                          Posts: 4384
                                          Message 13674 - Posted 8 Nov 2007 23:14:58 UTC

                                            Is it me, or is http://www.boincteams.com/ not available? I get an error "Firefox can't establish a connection to the server at www.boincteams.com."
                                            ____________
                                            Jord

                                            -The BOINC FAQ Service

                                            -CUDA/Stream FAQ

                                            Courtesy starts with your first post of the thread.

                                            zombie67
                                            Avatar
                                            Send message
                                            Joined: Feb 14 06
                                            Posts: 109
                                            Message 13675 - Posted 9 Nov 2007 2:41:47 UTC - in response to Message 13674.

                                              Is it me, or is http://www.boincteams.com/ not available? I get an error "Firefox can't establish a connection to the server at www.boincteams.com."

                                              Works for me.
                                              ____________
                                              Dublin, CA
                                              SETI.USA
                                              Stats
                                              My stuff
                                              BOINC IRC chat

                                              Les Bayliss
                                              Send message
                                              Joined: Nov 25 05
                                              Posts: 567
                                              Message 13678 - Posted 9 Nov 2007 4:35:34 UTC

                                                Works for me too.
                                                Netscape and Firefox.

                                                Profile KSMarksPsych
                                                Forum moderator
                                                Project administrator
                                                Avatar
                                                Send message
                                                Joined: Oct 30 05
                                                Posts: 1107
                                                Message 13687 - Posted 9 Nov 2007 12:27:07 UTC - in response to Message 13674.

                                                  Is it me, or is http://www.boincteams.com/ not available? I get an error "Firefox can't establish a connection to the server at www.boincteams.com."


                                                  Works for me, but the page is extremely slow to load.
                                                  ____________
                                                  Kathryn :o)
                                                  The BOINC FAQ Service
                                                  The Unofficial BOINC Wiki
                                                  The Trac System
                                                  More BOINC information than you can shake a stick of RAM at.

                                                  Pepo
                                                  Avatar
                                                  Send message
                                                  Joined: Apr 3 06
                                                  Posts: 403
                                                  Message 13784 - Posted 13 Nov 2007 14:35:17 UTC - in response to Message 13674.

                                                    Is it me, or is http://www.boincteams.com/ not available? I get an error "Firefox can't establish a connection to the server at www.boincteams.com."

                                                    I suppose that just you were withdrawn the access to the page ;-)

                                                    Peter

                                                    Profile Ageless
                                                    Forum moderator
                                                    Project administrator
                                                    Avatar
                                                    Send message
                                                    Joined: Aug 29 05
                                                    Posts: 4384
                                                    Message 13786 - Posted 13 Nov 2007 15:20:59 UTC - in response to Message 13784.

                                                      No, the day after it did load. Although hyper-slowly. Still not the fastest of places on the net. Then again, I know of a big project that's even slower. ;)

                                                      ____________
                                                      Jord

                                                      -The BOINC FAQ Service

                                                      -CUDA/Stream FAQ

                                                      Courtesy starts with your first post of the thread.

                                                      Heflin
                                                      Send message
                                                      Joined: Jun 26 07
                                                      Posts: 29
                                                      Message 13880 - Posted 15 Nov 2007 22:15:32 UTC - in response to Message 13406.

                                                        So there is no use for this "feature" for the second bigest team in BOINC, SETI.Germany.

                                                        To keep the same founder address may be usable, even for bigger teams, if some fake account is used to which more than one member have access, but the team description has to be project individual, not some boring, nonsensical, blah-blah without specialities for this project.

                                                        We have 28 founders on the BOINC projects, and we have a different description on all projects, with a standard part and some custom part in it. This has to stay this way, diversity is better than uniformity. If this "feature" will one day mess with our teams presentation, I think we will get unpleasant.

                                                        Who led this half-baked "feature" lose on the public?

                                                        Idea ....

                                                        If you setup your BOINC team with a general e-mail address (different from your project team founder e-mail address), then your team (by-the-same-name) on individual projects will not get updated.

                                                        If your team doesn't exist on a project (or new project), then your team name will get created with your general e-mail address. After team created, then you should be able to change founder's e-mail address to the individual who acts as team founder for THAT project.

                                                        ____________

                                                        Profile Saenger
                                                        Avatar
                                                        Send message
                                                        Joined: Nov 9 05
                                                        Posts: 104
                                                        Message 13882 - Posted 15 Nov 2007 22:21:08 UTC - in response to Message 13880.

                                                          Idea ....

                                                          If you setup your BOINC team with a general e-mail address (different from your project team founder e-mail address), then your team (by-the-same-name) on individual projects will not get updated.

                                                          If your team doesn't exist on a project (or new project), then your team name will get created with your general e-mail address. After team created, then you should be able to change founder's e-mail address to the individual who acts as team founder for THAT project.

                                                          That's how we will probably do it.

                                                          We thought about it several times, but originally decided against it. Now we are forced to do so, as if we will not use this BOINC wide teams, anyone can found a team called SETI.Germany on that list and we have even less control over it.

                                                          As David finally gave us our team back, we can now use it in this manner, unfortunately it took over a month because he didn't bother to ask us first is and how we liked to participate. In the projects set up after this implementation it will take us another month before we will have the team back via "initiate transfer" of the founder to some real persons.
                                                          ____________
                                                          Grüße vom Sänger


                                                          For questions about Boinc look in the BOINC-Wiki

                                                          Message boards : Web interfaces : Question to BOINC-wide Teams


                                                          BOINC home page | Log in | Create account

                                                          Copyright © 2009 University of California. Permission is granted to copy, distribute and/or modify this document under the terms of the GNU Free Documentation License, Version 1.2 or any later version published by the Free Software Foundation.